Phillies

Winter leagues

Transactions & Such

Buy my book


  • “Hard to Believe!” is the game-by-game story of the 2008 Philadelphia Phillies, from the first pitch on Opening Day to the final pitch of the World Series. Each game is captured in analytical detail by Philadelphia Magazine’s 2008 “Best Sportswriter” Jason Weitzel, along with photos, behind-the-scenes access and exclusive interviews by Michael McNesby, making this 370-page compendium a must-own for all fans.

Blogs

Part of CSNPhilly.com


Terms of Service

Go Phillies!


« Game chat: Phillies play first of three in Queens | Main | Sunday chat: Series victory in Oswalt's sights »

Saturday, September 11, 2010

Comments

jason.tp, I like Mike Sweeney, and I like the lighthouses.

If there was a just and loving god, Sweeney's ball would have been a homer.

Went to stubhub to see if lots of tickets for today were being dumped (iffy weather, NFL openers, etc) and was greeted with this up to the minute blurb...

Led by David Wright and Johan Santana, the Mets are looking solid and competitive this season..

Andy: "How about if we stop numbering our pitchers, like it's some excuse for Kendrick that he has a different number than Hamels?"

So you think every team's 5th starter should be able to pitch like its ace?

Stick to haikus.

Clout, I think he was talking about in terms of run support.

If Hamels had the run support that Kendrick's gotten this season, the Phils would probably have 3 to 4 more win.

At least that's what I got from his posts.

But, he does write some great haikus.

Phillies recalled SS Brian Bocock from Triple-A Lehigh Valley.

As bad as Bocock is, this is a good move. You box yourself in when you have only backup for both 2B and SS. This will allow Charlie to PH for Valdes when Rollins or Utley have to sit.

Fatalotti: To prove that statement you'd have to go thru Kendrick's starts game by game. Run support is an average, which means if a team score 15 runs in 1 game and then 3 a game for 4 more, it looks like a pitcher was winning only because he got 5 or 6 runs per game.

In any event, that's not how I read Andy's post.

Yo, new thread

Let's examine the players sent to the Indians in the Cliff Lee trade.

1. Jason Donald. Hailed as a future star by posters here because of his bat, some noted that his range at SS would prevent him from being an acceptable everyday SS. He projected better at 2B, assuming his bat was for real. Has been splitting time between the 2 positions, but the bat hasn't been anything special (.690 OPS) and he strikes out too much for a guy who doesn't hit many HRs. You may recall he dazzled evryone in Reading in 2008, but wasn't very good at LV in '09 partly due to injury. I think his bat will improve (he's 25) but don't think he'll be a .300 hitter. Decent doubles power should keep him in MLB as an everyday 2B for a bad team or solid sub for a good team.

2. Carlos Carrasco. Most posters here soured on him becaused he was hyped as a #1 SP and he was never able to carry his dazzling A ball numbers to higher levels. Started slow at LV last year, but his K/9 was solid and he showed sharp improvement after the trade at Columbus. He was always young for his levels and the struggles at AA and AAA probably should've been expected. Has looked very good in 3 starts for the Indians. Won't be an ace, but at age 23 he projects as a decent #2 or #3 starter for years to come.

3. Lou Marson. Another prospect much beloved on Beerleaguer. As one of the Phils top prospects, scouts loved his bat but had concerns about his defense after his seasons at Clearwater and Reading. Oddly, he has become just the opposite. His arm was never in question but he made a lot of throwing errors and his footwork behind the plate was considreed weak. That's all fixed now, but the bat disappeared. He hit .243 in a half season at Columbus last year, .202 in a half season there this year and .196 in 74 games for Cleveland. Marson didn't show much with the bat in his first 3 pro seasons so now we're forced to wonder if those 2 years at Clearwater and Reading were outliers. I think the bat will improve, but he's looking more like a career backup.

4. Jason Knapp. Hard thrower with big K/9 rate, some scouts thought his ceiling higher than Carrasco's. Was identified in Cleveland media as the key to the Lee trade. Last season cut short by shoulder surgery, he's made just 9 starts this season and the numbers suggest he's recovered nicely: 47 K in 28 IP. He'll play in the Arizona Instructional League and at age 19 still projects as a potential ace.

Morality may consist solely in the courage of making a choice. (Leon Nlum, French statesman)

The comments to this entry are closed.

EST. 2005

Phillies Ticker

Contact Weitzel

DREXEL LEBOW MBA


Rotoworld News

Advertisements


Follow on Twitter

HardballTalk

Beerleaguer Shop

Beat Blogs

Follow on Facebook

CSG


Beerleaguer 2012