Brewers outfielder Corey Hart and Mets third baseman David Wright finished ahead of Phillies left fielder Pat Burrell in the final fan voting. Wright was invited to the team to replace Alfonso Soriano.
Hart is hitting 292/.332/.510 with 14 home runs and 56 RBIs, while Wright is hitting .285/386/.511 with 17 homers and 70 RBIs. Burrell is hitting .279/.412/.581 with 22 homers and 54 RBIs, and is also leading all NL outfielders with a .933 OPS.
Beerleaguer: Fans will vote as they please, and I suppose the Milwaukee faithful were feeling especially giddy about their team following the acquisition of CC Sabathia. On the flipside, the Phillies’ recent struggles probably kept Burrell supporters away. Everyone knew Wright would get plenty of support in New York. If the voting wasn’t a popularity contest, designed to drum up page traffic and collect e-mail information for MLB promotional purposes, Burrell wins by a nose.
The rule about having at least one player from each team never bothered me. I understand the reasoning, I like the variety and actually get a kick out of seeing that one, solitary member from teams like Kansas City (Joakim Soria) standing by his lonesome when lineups are announced. The problem is that many times, they select a closer from these teams. My all-time favorite is the Pirates' Mike Williams back in 2002. Everyone knew Williams was smoke and mirrors, except for Ed Wade, who traded for him a month later. And of course, Ricky Botallico represented the same idea with the Phils back in 1996.
So with Wright aboard as the No. 2 vote-getter, I’m especially bothered by the inclusion of other players, like some of the other outfielders, but also Billy Wagner, who’s there because the Mets needed a rep. He’s having a good, but not great, season. Metsblog graded him as a “B” so far, which basically means he’s done his job. What’s the difference between what Wagner has done for his team and, say, Kyle Kendrick? I’d give Kendrick a “B,” too.
Whenever possible, the All-Star team should be a place to reward players who are having grade-A, special seasons, which is what Burrell is having. The NL roster is padded with far to many players who would earn 'Bs' on their report cards.
Today’s stat: 3.95. That’s Jamie Moyer’s ERA. Not too shabby. No. 2 material, maybe? Based on no particular stat, Moyer is a top 20 NL starter. At his best, that’s what Brett Myers was.
Good links: Because of the 1 o’clock game, Philadelphia’s finest used the early deadlines to pen some excellent team features the morning after the Phillies defeated the Cardinals 4-1.
I invite everyone to bookmark a couple informative pieces for future reference. Matt Gelb, Staff Writer at the Inquirer, offered a nice feature on top prospect Carlos Carrasco, with the premise being “He doesn’t even know how good he’s going to be.” Reading pitching coach Tom Filer and catcher Lou Marson are interviewed. Speaking of Marson, Todd Zolecki explains why Carlos Ruiz’s job is secure, and where Marson and Jason Jaramillo are in their development.